Cordless string trimmer

kennith

Well-known member
Apr 22, 2004
10,891
172
North Carolina
I just bought a cordless string trimmer. That would seem like a stupid move, but I had my reasons. The Echo trimmer I have, I bought for very heavy stuff, and though it pretty much sucks, it does do the rough brush decently enough.

I became fed up with getting it started to maintain my lawn, however. It is a bear to get going, it leaks all it's fuel out overnight. Before you suggest I fix it, know that I have. Many times. I don't know what the heck is the issue, something must porous some where. I've replaced everything on it.

Well, I needed a new trimmer that wouldn't be so damn wasteful. I've been using shears instead of the Echo, and you can imagine how annoying that was.

So, knowing that my lawn didn't require too much of a trimmer, I went out looking for cordless models. As expected most of them just felt like junk.

I found one, however that was different. Lowes had it. It is branded as a Troy-Bilt, but I don't know who makes it. Either way, it was of significantly higher quality than all the others. It is made in China, but all of them are, unfortunately. I suppose one could call it the best of the worst.

It uses a 20v Li-ion battery pack, which charges in around 4 hours from dead. The pack has a battery life indicator button and a few LEDs on the back, to see how much juice you have left. That sounds like a gimmick, but if it proves to be accurate, I expect it will come in handy. The lithium battery prevents memory development to a large extent, and also ensures full power delivery right up until the moment it tanks.

It uses an automatic feed, single line cartridge, which I'm told can be manually reloaded, but I haven't tried yet. It comes with .060 line, but it is supposed to accept up to .080.

Surprisingly, it seemed to have just as much grunt as most home-oriented gas-powered trimmers. I mean, it's not going to out-cut a Stihl, and you aren't putting a circular blade on it any time soon, but I didn't find anything I couldn't cut with it. I didn't feel as if I was limited in any way over the Echo when it is running. I didn't have to take any extra care at all, actually, I just went about trimming my lawn.

When I was done with that, I went into some heavy brush that I hadn't bothered with in months. As long as it isn't a sapling, or other woody-barked brush, the bugger will eat right through it. Heavy grass, weeds, whatever. The thick stuff might take a couple of bites to eat through, but it will do it.

I also found, due to the lack of a hot engine, and partially due to the excellent balance of the unit, that I could extend one arm out and hold it, sweeping behind dense bushes and things without actually having to crawl back there.

About the time I was really starting to play with it, I realized that I hadn't run the battery down yet. I had forgotten that I was using a cordless trimmer.

Guys, I think they might have finally cracked it. I think someone has finally figured out how to build a cordless trimmer that actually works. Landscaping crews won't be using it any time soon, but I think it will be fine for around the house for most people, and even for more strenuous work at homes with tougher than average plants to deal with.

I expect the battery will probably hold for 30-45 minutes or so, it is difficult to tell. I think I was out for 15-20 minutes, but I can't be sure. As strange as this sounds, one of my faults is a complete lack of a functional sense of time. Either way, the indicator suggested that I had only used 1/4 of it's reserve. I'll find out in the future, as I didn't have much to do today.

I'll also test to see if it can manage edging gardens. I think I may need the .080 line to do that, but we will see. Even if it just can't do that, it is a hell of a machine so far.

If the performance holds up over the long run, I'll be happy with it for around the house, and perhaps even more.

The bugger isn't cheap, but it sure does seem to work. We will see how it does in the future.

Cheers,

Kennith
 

95.D1.Rick

Well-known member
Apr 20, 2004
402
0
Cumberland Co., ME
Nice, if they make a hedge trimmer that uses the same battery I need em both. I hate the noise of a gas trimmer. If you do need to get a gas string trimmer, check out the OTHER German company, Dolmar. They are better than Stihl (says alot) but you dont know it because they dont advertise as much, and arent established as much in U.S.A.market
 

kennith

Well-known member
Apr 22, 2004
10,891
172
North Carolina
It was 160 dollars when I bought it, but it was on sale. They are normally 170 I think.

That makes it a full 70 dollars more than the competition from Black and Decker. I've used it twice now, and I've only charged it once. Of course, your mileage will vary. I don't know much about it's long term durability, but I expect it will hold up decently enough.

As for the charge time, they claim that their battery won't self-discharge. I'm sure it will but I'll bet it won't be near as bad for it as others. They say that when the battery is full and idle, it is managed by it's internal circuitry, and keeps itself from discharging until it is being used. Thus, it is possible to leave it on the charger.

They do recommend unplugging the charger if you are to leave the battery in there for long periods of time. There can be many reasons for this.

The battery is near a work of art on this thing, and I expect the lithium system on the whole is what brings the price so high up on this model. It seems that they put a lot of effort into the design, and it is a darn big battery.

I'm not worried about the charge time. It charges faster than my hard drive defrags. :)

It isn't like I'm going to have to charge it constantly. From what I can tell, I'll be able to trim my yard at least twice on a charge, if I don't use it as an edger. That means two weeks before I'll have to charge it for four hours. It seems to have enough grunt to use as an edger in a limited capacity, though, so I may start doing that when I get my gardens ready for it. There may be enough reserve left after the normal trimming to allow edging once every two weeks without an extra charge.

The thing about the battery capacity is, this isn't like a gas trimmer. When it is idling, it is off. Nothing at all is going on until you press that trigger. So, as you walk from place to place with it, it isn't using power. So, flat out, running constantly, it may not last that long in the end, but that isn't how trimmers are used. Half the time you have a trimmer in your hand, it is idling.

This trimmer doesn't need to idle. Like a power drill, it doesn't do a thing until you pull the trigger. Spin-up is fast, and the trigger allows for variable speed, though I ran it at full speed both times. It will cut easier materials at lower speeds.

I don't know if they have any other products that use the same battery, and I don't know how much the replacement might be, but I expect it will be expensive. That battery makes those expensive power drill batteries look like button cells in comparison.

For someone with a small enough yard to manage cords, those 40 dollar Craftsman plug-in trimmers would be a far cheaper and more simple choice. They are built well for what they are, and they do a great job. My yard was too big for the cords, though, so I needed something else.

My favorite part of this is the lack of anything to leak. Brush it off after use, and you are done. You can store it in your living room if you want, it doesn't smell, there is nothing to leak, and you can hang it any way you want without fear.

If the performance holds up, and I'm not certifying that it will, this is going to be one heck of a lawn care product for the average person. I still may need the muscle of a big, gas-powered behemoth of a trimmer for my other properties, but now I don't need to use one every week to trim my lawn. Believe me, that is worth 170 bucks and more.
 

kennith

Well-known member
Apr 22, 2004
10,891
172
North Carolina
Like I said, there is a 30 day return policy. If it doesn't do what you need it to do, no worries, just take it back. I think, for around the house, it is perfect. I'm no longer dreading trimming my yard, and that is worth the money.

And by the powers, don't buy a damn Echo! Go ahead and get something nicer if you need a gas trimmer. I'm about one cord-pull away from snapping my Echo in half out of frustration.

Cheers,

Kennith
 

DiscoJen

Well-known member
Aug 27, 2004
3,652
0
54
The Lou!
Has anyone checked out or tried the Worx GT trimmer? I've been eyeing it but afraid to make the jump from my little reliable electric trimmer. And lord knows I'm sick and tired of dragging extension cords from the basement outlet out the window and across the yard.
 

kennith

Well-known member
Apr 22, 2004
10,891
172
North Carolina
I thought about it, I really did. What I kept hearing about it was a bunch of yuppies on Amazon who said it was wimpy. Now, if a yuppie says it's wimpy, that's enough for me. I'm not interested.

The concept behind it is kind of stupid, though, when you think about it. Who cares if you can twist it to edge or not. It is an electric trimmer with no cord, just turn it sideways. Hell, you can even do that with a gas trimmer.

I really can't comment on it beyond a bunch of wimps saying that it is wimpy. :) I'd be happy if it turns out to be a good product, though, because competition breeds excellence. I think it's time the manufacturers really put thought into these things.

Cheers,

Kennith
 

DiscoJen

Well-known member
Aug 27, 2004
3,652
0
54
The Lou!
Hmmm those are pretty cool. My electric trimmer is a Troy-Bilt and I abuse the shit outta that thing and it keeps on working. Same thing with my old blower, can't kill the damn thing. I'm pretty anal retentive about how my yard looks so having a cordless trimmer AND blower would be the cats ass for me. Hmm, and I DOOOOO have that $400 check coming from my previous employer...
 

kennith

Well-known member
Apr 22, 2004
10,891
172
North Carolina
Well, I've trimmed several times with it, and the battery finally died about 5 minutes ago. Admittedly, I don't have the most trimming in the world to do, but I've been trimming off any on since I started the thread, and it's lasted this long. I must have at least around 45 minutes of trimming on it by now.

The automatic cord feed has worked as advertised, no worries there.

So, battery life is not going to be any issue at all for most people.

Cheers,

Kennith
 

Roverlady

Well-known member
Apr 20, 2004
7,825
0
45
Shenandoah valley
I've been trying to convince my husband to get one of these for a while....our trimmer is older, gas powered, a PIA to start and keep running, and too heavy for me. SO, he does all the trimming.

I'm really interested in how long you can use it on one charge--you said you think about 45 minutes? I'm pretty sure we have at least that much trimming to do at one time around our place....so that's a problem. But, I could use it in the front yard....charge in the evening and then do the back yard the next day.
 

t1r_dc5

Well-known member
Oct 7, 2008
124
0
Hendersonville, NC
flyfisher11 said:
For gas medium duty commercial grade you can't wrong with RedMax and Shindaiwa
I fully back their stuff and put it to use alot. Higher end echo stuff is good too, also shindy and echo are one in the same now!


There also a few lawn companies I have heard of using electric push mowers, electric trimmers, the works. All of which is recharged by a solar panel on the top of their trucks. Its pretty neat!
 

kennith

Well-known member
Apr 22, 2004
10,891
172
North Carolina
Roverlady said:
I've been trying to convince my husband to get one of these for a while....our trimmer is older, gas powered, a PIA to start and keep running, and too heavy for me. SO, he does all the trimming.

I'm really interested in how long you can use it on one charge--you said you think about 45 minutes? I'm pretty sure we have at least that much trimming to do at one time around our place....so that's a problem. But, I could use it in the front yard....charge in the evening and then do the back yard the next day.

Remember that much of trimming time is spent idling. This only uses energy when you pull the trigger. It's got a 30 day return policy. Note it with the manager of the Lowes, and just try one. Even the manliest of men has to get a kick out of this, gasoline or not.

It's just a great idea that finally works. They will get even better than this eventually, I'm sure.

On a side note, I saw something very, very cool at Sears. A propane string trimmer!

Cheers,

Kennith