Put me in the 'yes' column.
I don't drive the vehicle in especially dusty conditions, so that's not really an issue for me. I've had one in my Disco for 50,000km with no problem. It was recommended to me by a local LR independent mechanic, and my dealership was quietly supportive of using it even while the truck was under warranty.
I've tried them in a bunch of cars I've owned, with widely varying results ranging from actually hurting performance (a BMW) to fantastic improvement (a Jeep Wrangler). Not always worth it. In the Disco, butt dyno noted a slight improvement at highway speeds, and that was about it. Confused by the noise comment above... I've never heard a difference. With CAI, yes, but not with just the filter.
I'd do it again, but it's not a miracle.