thats the odd thing. i could see a thermostat sticking somewhat open or closed but not both.
we see the plastic impellar water pumps (VAG cars) cause intermittent over heating, but that wouldn't cause lower coolant temps. but we have metal impellars.
with a clogged radiator i could see hotter operating temps but not cooler temps.
intermittent fan clutch locked up or not operating can cause erratic temps.
without splicing a sender housing in the outlet hose and verifying actual temps......
whenever we have this guys scenario we always start with a vacuum bleed to verify any and all air bubbles are evacuated. could be a leak or exhaust gas causing air bubbles.
How much would you estimate a vacuum bleed to cost? Can any radiator shop do it, or should I stick to a rover shop? If my attempt at bleeding doesn't work, I think I'll try a new expansion tank/cap, rad fill plug and a vacuum bleed.