Masonite Siding Replacement

ChrismonDA

Well-known member
May 2, 2004
1,873
0
51
NC Johnston Co
My house that was owned by my grandfather has that crappy Masonite siding that is starting to rot. I do not want to replace with vinyl or aluminum because it is the lower parts of the house that is bad. What can I substitute it with? How hard is it to remove and replace? Any help would be appreciated. It is white in color and I really hate it.
 

garrett

Well-known member
Jun 18, 2004
10,931
5
53
Middleburg, VA
www.blackdogmobility.com
HardiPlank or cedar is my choice. Just depends on what you want to spend. We did cedar on our house in Nova Scotia. Mainly because it sits about 100 feet from the ocean in a very rough climate during the end of summer and winter months and holds up very well. I believe it was about 30% more than HardiPlank, but nothing weathers quite as nice as cedar.
 

Attachments

  • NS.jpg
    NS.jpg
    71.3 KB · Views: 48
  • NS2.jpg
    NS2.jpg
    52.6 KB · Views: 41
  • Like
Reactions: ChrismonDA

chris snell

Administrator
Staff member
Aug 15, 2005
3,020
152
Hardiplank is awesome. Our house is covered in it. Looks like wood when painted but tough as nails.

bqF2qxe.jpg


xjrdrKe.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: ChrismonDA

ArmyRover

Well-known member
Dec 4, 2007
3,230
1
Augusta, GA
HardiPlank or cedar is my choice. Just depends on what you want to spend. We did cedar on our house in Nova Scotia. Mainly because it sits about 100 feet from the ocean in a very rough climate during the end of summer and winter months and holds up very well. I believe it was about 30% more than HardiPlank, but nothing weathers quite as nice as cedar.

Damn, now that is a view!
 
  • Like
Reactions: ChrismonDA

chris snell

Administrator
Staff member
Aug 15, 2005
3,020
152
The paint doesn't seem to chip or flake. It adheres well. Our paint looks like shit because our house is a dark blue and those fade very quickly.
 

bri

Well-known member
Apr 20, 2004
6,184
155
US
Not sure if you have experience with cedar or redwood in CO. I would not do a house in it. My reason is because (at least) south facing exposure will require annual re-stain if you do not go opaque. I have cedar and opaque stain that is not oil based so it goes bad very quickly. The opaque stain will last a couple years on cedar.


Redwood decks and proper natural stain have worked well, but they are quick for me to touch up and they are not full south facing.


Cedar/redwood without oil will deteriorate VERY quickly at 7000ft and direct sun will eat through any stain that is not oil based. In fact I would say anything other than oil is a waste of time in CO.


I also have about a million wood peckers, flickers, etc. Natural wood with natural stain is VERY attractive to them.


I have never seen a cedar house in my area that looked nearly like garrets.


I think I will go with the hardie plank staggered shingle product, but windows are first.
 

garrett

Well-known member
Jun 18, 2004
10,931
5
53
Middleburg, VA
www.blackdogmobility.com
My parents house in PA is cedar single as well - built in 1987 and still looks great (pic taken two summers ago - not a great image). A few wood pecker holes here and there. We built the Nova Scotia house around 2000 I believe. Neither sidings have been touched since construction. NS shore gets a crazy amount of abuse from the hurricanes and major storms that come up in late summer every year. Lots of damage over the years, but the cedar holds up well. The PA house has a stain on it (that I painted one summer in high school) and the NS house is natural. Odd thing is some of the bees like the stain and have been taking it off over the years. I prefer the natural.

Second pic is of a small building we had moved to the NS house property this year. "Old Snorer's" cottage that is around 100 years old. Hard to say if that cedar is original or not, but it can hold up for a century easy enough as seen throughout New England and coastal areas.

The house I live in now is hardiplank (last pic) - it's nice and seems to hold up very well, but it won't compare to cedar in terms of looks though IMHO. The hardiplank on the house I live in now was reused from the main house next door when they remodeled - still looks great.

The NS house is available for rent in the summer. Just let me know! ;) It's located about 10 min from Lunenburg and very private setting. It's a good two hour plus drive to Cape Breton. Has beach access as well and an "off road" golf cart with surf boards, etc.
 

Attachments

  • cedarrunhouse1.jpg
    cedarrunhouse1.jpg
    83 KB · Views: 18
  • snorerscottage2.jpg
    snorerscottage2.jpg
    206.7 KB · Views: 20
  • house.jpg
    house.jpg
    110.3 KB · Views: 22

Beagle Bones

Well-known member
Oct 5, 2010
325
0
Nashville
Give LP Building products a look. Hardiboard is a concrete mix. LP is wood based. Warranty is similar, the LP is easier to work with. I just replaced all the Masonite siding on my garage, last year, w/LP and couldn't be happier. I was a fan of Hardiboard, as I'd used it in the past, until I got a chance to use LP. I'll be replacing the siding on my house w/LP when $ allows.
 

ChrismonDA

Well-known member
May 2, 2004
1,873
0
51
NC Johnston Co
Give LP Building products a look. Hardiboard is a concrete mix. LP is wood based. Warranty is similar, the LP is easier to work with. I just replaced all the Masonite siding on my garage, last year, w/LP and couldn't be happier. I was a fan of Hardiboard, as I'd used it in the past, until I got a chance to use LP. I'll be replacing the siding on my house w/LP when $ allows.


Thanks will take a look and do some pricing.