Mountain bikers, need some recommendations

fishEH

Well-known member
Jan 26, 2009
6,930
203
Lake Villa, IL
New bike prices are retarded. I could buy a few more Discos for the price of one, so I'll be looking for a "pre-owned" bike.

Lookinh for a XC style, dual suspension, 29" wheels.
I need recommendations on a few to keep an eye out for.
Any thoughts?

My current bike is a 2003 era Stumpjumper hardtail. Light as a feather but I need some more cushion in my old age. :D
The old hoopdie.
 
Last edited:

ERover82

Well-known member
Nov 26, 2011
3,927
460
Darien Gap
Bought my carbon fiber Trek Remedy from a bike shop owner who sells his personal bike every year to stay current. Since it was shop inventory (regardless of his use) and never sold until then it came with a full factory warranty. Saved 3k doing it that way.
 

Tugela

Well-known member
May 21, 2007
4,767
567
Seattle
Both my mountain bikes are from the last millennium. One is a 1993 Klein Rascal, fully rigid, weighs nothing and is loads of fun on reasonably smooth trails. Other is a 1999 Klein Mantra, full suspension, and is loads of fun on everything.

I like my mountain bikes like I like my Rovers: old, fun, full of character. Although to be honest, my mountain bikes give me zero mechanical issues - wish I could say the same of my Disco.

But to your question, I'd look around locally for bikes that are a couple years old. I don't know about your neck of the woods, but round these parts there are always dudes with more money than practical sense who buy a new bike every season or two. A recent model used bike could be a great way to find what you want on a modest budget (relative to new, anyway). Santa Cruz full suspension 29ers are wildly popular among my circle of riding friends. I borrowed one and found out why.

The 29" wheel is great for going downhill in a straight line, or for riding over larger obstacles, but once you get into technical singletrack XC terrain all that extra weight and momentum of the bigger wheel becomes harder to handle. There is nothing like a good old 26" wheel for light weight and precision handling. Pushing the bigger wheels around - both in terms of steering and propulsion - is a lot more work. Something else to consider in your old age.
 

jymmiejamz

Well-known member
Dec 5, 2004
6,010
362
36
Los Angeles, Ca
I know you want full suspension, but I have a Niner that I want to sell. It is a really nice bike, but I have only used it once since I moved to NYC. It is a size medium.

 

ukoffroad

Well-known member
Jan 13, 2010
2,128
169
Lynchburg, Va
X2 on the lightly used. I saw a Trek Fuel used in Feb for $600 that was 4 years old and still in good shape. Someone bought it on a whim I am sure, did not look like it had been ridden much.
 

KingKong8247

Well-known member
Feb 11, 2007
117
0
NJ
Picked up a Salsa Spearfish a couple years ago for relatively cheap. I think its a 2013 model with full suspension 29er that has handled everything I've thrown at it so far.
 

MM3846

Well-known member
Feb 18, 2014
1,232
164
LI, NY
check pinkbike.com classifieds. I know people love to push the 27.5s but IMHO if you at or close to 6' or taller just go to a 29. They aren't the clumsy bikes they used to be.

I have an Airborne Goblin Evo hardtail 29. Love it. They don't make em anymore though. What's your budget and what do you plan on doing? You can get something from bikesdirect pretty cheap if the used market in your area sucks and you aren't trying to drop $2000 on a bike.
 

Ballah06

Well-known member
Jan 21, 2007
5,638
16
Savannah, GA
Will have to check on the specific model of mine but upgraded from a hardtail Gary Fisher in 2007-8 to a Trek Fuel and love it. Been riding it more lately. Would highly recommend one if you can find it for a decent price; think it was around $2300 or so brand new. Although that price seems to pale in comparison to some other models like Ghost - just got an email from REI about them carrying those. They looks sweet, but damn, eeeexpeeensive.
 

Va_Disco

Well-known member
Dec 22, 2014
106
6
Hampton Roads, Va.
Is your current bike a 29er? I am in the market for a new bike as well and have tested many and have decided on a 27.5, The new 29ers are much better then when they first came out but I still find that the front wheel is not pushed out enough in most cases and you can contact it with the tip of your foot in a cornering situation. I didn't run into this at all with the 27.5.
 

Maximumwarp

Well-known member
Mar 22, 2015
836
26
Fairburn GA
I've always preferred hardtails to full suspensions. Unless it's done right (and I've never ridden a fuel, so I can't speak to that design) I always feel like the rear shock eats the pedal energy when you get out of the saddle. I rode a Specialized Epic at a demo one time that still felt like a hardtail. They had some proprietary valving in the shock that could somehow tell the difference between pedaling and bumps, and would lock itself up during pedaling to minimize the power loss. It was the S-works version, though, so a $9k bike. I don't know how far down the product line that design trickles.
 

Ballah06

Well-known member
Jan 21, 2007
5,638
16
Savannah, GA
I've always preferred hardtails to full suspensions. Unless it's done right (and I've never ridden a fuel, so I can't speak to that design) I always feel like the rear shock eats the pedal energy when you get out of the saddle. I rode a Specialized Epic at a demo one time that still felt like a hardtail. They had some proprietary valving in the shock that could somehow tell the difference between pedaling and bumps, and would lock itself up during pedaling to minimize the power loss. It was the S-works version, though, so a $9k bike. I don't know how far down the product line that design trickles.


Agreed on the hardtail type preference - use it majority of the time. I do dig the Fuel because it has the selector to engage the full suspension, if needed. I can see it coming in handy on pretty rough terrain where you'd want the rear to stick vs. bounce around. You definitely do lose some energy as you mentioned when using the full suspension.
 

honda50r

Well-known member
Jul 10, 2011
1,208
0
East Tennessee
PinkBike is a great resource but you may not find the bargain you're looking for. I buy/sell high-end bikes often and always find my best deals via Craigslist. Also find buy/sell groups on Facebook.

Don't listen to the purists, 26" wheels are all but obsolete and soon all aftermarket parts will be strictly 27.5/29. If you are strictly a XC guy nothing beats a 29".

The biking community tends to have a market segment with lots of disposable income. You should be able to find a 2-3 year old full squish that someone has "upgraded" from or they decided "MTB is not for me." They will sell their old bike for cheap.
 

ERover82

Well-known member
Nov 26, 2011
3,927
460
Darien Gap
Dweb excels in the obsolete..

The Fuel may have quick rear lockout or the feature that preserves pedaling energy.
 

MM3846

Well-known member
Feb 18, 2014
1,232
164
LI, NY
Any new full squish that you didn't buy in walmart is going to have a rear shock and/or geometry that preserves pedal energy and makes bikes from 5 years ago seem like they ride like doodoo.