2004 Discovery or 2005 LR3

Eriazon

Well-known member
Sep 24, 2005
362
0
36
CA
Ok, next question. Would it be better to pusrchase froma dealer or a private party?
 

stolenheron

Well-known member
May 1, 2008
1,861
0
Hattiesburg, MS
totally depends on your price range, intended usage, and what you want from the d2.

I got mine from a dealership with 16k miles (358 days ago) with an extended warranty and at below kbb value. It was a steal. I got a good price, low miles, clean title, and a dealer backed warranty I can depend on. I still am modifying the car, but not at such a rate where my warranty is voided. its a daily driven street car which i take offroad whenever I can.

now if you want to make a trail rig outta your 2004, go with a private party, more than likely prices can be bargained lower, no warranty to void. mod away.

dealerships give you piece of mind, but ass a pain in the ass.

private parties give you a good price and usually have a wider selection
 

specops1526

Well-known member
Jan 17, 2007
845
11
Los Angeles, CA
Don't think it makes a difference whether or not you buy from a private party or a dealer regarding your warranty. As long as your 04 is still under warranty the dealer will cover issues. Also if there is enough warranty remaining, you have the option to purchase an extended warranty. I think with a Private Party you have the option to bargain more and prices will most likely be lower to start with. I purchased my 04 SE (Love it so far!) from an independent dealer in Texas, got it for a decent price with 35K on the clock. Brought it back here to SoCal and my dealer does any warranty work on it whenever I bring it in. As a matter of fact, two dealers near me honor the warranty and when I had a buyer's inspection done on it at Land Rover Dallas, they fixed any issues on it that were covered under warranty. This was before I even owned it. Good Luck!
 

stolenheron

Well-known member
May 1, 2008
1,861
0
Hattiesburg, MS
you're correct in some aspects of a warranty. but the opportunity to purchase a certified used land rover with the certified extended warranty is not an option from a private party. you may buy an aftermarket extended warranty through an independent company as long as you're car is still under the original factory warranty, which is an option if you buy with a private party.
 

specops1526

Well-known member
Jan 17, 2007
845
11
Los Angeles, CA
My Dealer has offered me the Land Rover Extended Warranty even though I did not buy the truck through an LR dealer. I have however gone to other dealers and have only been offered an aftermarket one. I'm not sure and I guess it depends on the amount of warranty left and the dealership but I've seen some come with an extended warranty as an incentive to buy through them.
 

LANDO0077

Well-known member
Jun 12, 2006
77
0
Raleigh
stolenheron said:
I must disagree saying the LR3 wins. I've driven both on the same trails as you have. They both got me through just as quickly, but in two different fashions. the Lr3 would be good if you don't get your kicks from the bouncy rugged rid of a discovery. The lr3 is smooth, and the driver doesn't do shit. Its comfortable, and quick on the street, but its also a lazy ride and is quite boring on the trails stock for stock compared to a 2004 D2. I'd much rather wheel my 04 than wheel my dad's CDL. Its a much less electronically, automatic ride than the LR3. the Auto-pilot like style of the electronic terrain response system is a sweet feature, and i'd love it on the D2, but it also kills some of the thrill of something like the discoveries had.

I'm not saying the LR3 is definetly worse than a D2 stock for stock. It is a land rover, you will make it through, but the LR3 and D2 (like their on road abilities) vary greatly in the style/manner in which you arive at your destination.




As I am sure I said before, the LR3 does have the mindless driving on and off road.

I mean some people go to Outback for a good meal and others like the better meal of Ruth's Chris, either way you are eating steak.

If the guy gets a DII then good, If not, I dont give two shits. I was simply stating that I would drive my LR3 1000 miles for every 100 on the DII. I like them both.

I am about to buy the Cayenne Turbo, it has 500 hp and 6 settings on the air suspension, doesnt have the terrain response but neither does the ever so popular DII. More to follow on this next month, I will put the G/f in the LR3 and see if she has to pull the Cayenne out of any sticky situations.

http://www.porsche.com/usa/models/cayenne/cayenne-turbo/indetail/offroad/
 
B

brooksa

Guest
Damn LANDO0077, whatever you do you must do it well!!lol.....nice garage!
 

Eriazon

Well-known member
Sep 24, 2005
362
0
36
CA
Ok, So I found a 04 DII S in good condition, 85K miles on it. Is that high mileage for a 4 year old car?
 

Blue

Well-known member
Mar 26, 2004
10,071
881
AZ
Eriazon said:
Ok, So I found a 04 DII S in good condition, 85K miles on it. Is that high mileage for a 4 year old car?

Yeah, that is high mileage for a 2004. What's the asking price?
 

Blue

Well-known member
Mar 26, 2004
10,071
881
AZ
michaels said:
for 5000 more bucks, i'd definitely get the DII. i paid almost twice that for one with 40K miles.

Agreed.

85K miles is high, but $10,900 is a low price. Any maintenance history?

I picked up my 2004 DII with 49,850 miles for $11,500 + $2,000 for a 5yr/100K mi powertrain warranty. But it was a small local dealer so I had to pay tax too.
 

Eriazon

Well-known member
Sep 24, 2005
362
0
36
CA
They said its had the regular maintenance history. I am not sure what that means. but nothing major. Regular fluid and brake pad change.