Seems simple to me. Rover engines die occasionally from sludge, synthetic oil doesn't tend to turn to sludge, even cleans it up some, ... I run mine on Mobil 1 or Amsoil, change at 12,000miles, at 89,000 it is clean as new in the valve covers and uses no measurable oil at 12,000miles (doesn't even leak believe it or not). The change interval pays for the oil, the fuel mileage is good, the engine is clean, and I dump less oil into the environment than the 3000mile guys.
I won't tell anyone that they **should** use synthetic, but I also don't believe that telling people that they shouldn't or that it isn't better is a little inaccurate, it's just more money/quart and a personal decision.
It is one of the more common arguments on the 'net though, there's always someone who has never changed their oil in 200,000miles and doesn't burn a quart ...
- Jeff