People make fun of the ARB bumpers, but I've found them to be top quality with great fit and doesn't look home made.
D1 bumpers (assuming no crush can version here) are super tough and stout. I have never had the rotating bumper problem as I used three bolts per frame rail, but I have totaled a car with one and drove away with literally one scratch on the bumper, which because of ARBs fantastic powder coating never flaked off, or rusted beyond the scratch.
The only issue is the bumper sticks out a little far, but if you are not rock crawling it shouldn't effect you.