Decently Priced Field Watch

p m

Administrator
Staff member
Apr 19, 2004
15,634
864
58
La Jolla, CA
www.3rj.org
Re: Decently Priced Field Watched

The Shinola and Filson watches are nice but I'm not going to drop $500 + on a quartz movement watch just because it's 'assembled' in Detroit.
No, it's because they are really nice watches.
I like Shinola more than I like the TAG. Not in a small part because I can barely see Tag's slim hands on top of a black dial - compared to that:

watches_s_01_00111_f2_1150x1150.jpg


That's all I ever need in a watch, field or not. Leather strap will eventually have to go.
 

MM3846

Well-known member
Feb 18, 2014
1,223
161
LI, NY
Re: Decently Priced Field Watched

No, it's because they are really nice watches.
I like Shinola more than I like the TAG. Not in a small part because I can barely see Tag's slim hands on top of a black dial - compared to that:

watches_s_01_00111_f2_1150x1150.jpg


That's all I ever need in a watch, field or not. Leather strap will eventually have to go.

That's exactly the one I have. Everything you need, nothing you don't.
 

riceybean

Well-known member
Jun 29, 2008
861
0
Vancouver, WA

emmodg

Well-known member
Apr 17, 2006
4,273
1
Re: Decently Priced Field Watched

I put "field watch" in quotes for the simple fact that it's a bit of a marketing term used now by every watch maker slapping a nato, Zulu, or hipster leather band on an analog watch and calling it a "field watch". The style has been around for ages. A true watch FOR the field did not have any complications. Shilnola seems to have the "look" squared away but I too have to admit that I wouldn't pay $500 for a watch with a quartz movement built by newly trained watch makers in Detroit. Hamilton still makes a great mechanical watch with an ETA movement. Watches are like wine though - There's no such thing as the "best" watch.
 

ERover82

Well-known member
Nov 26, 2011
3,919
458
Darien Gap
Re: Decently Priced Field Watched

What I use. Two Timex and a Citizen BM8475-26E, the most expensive at $115.

IMG_1922.jpg
 

kennith

Well-known member
Apr 22, 2004
10,891
172
North Carolina
Re: Decently Priced Field Watched

The style has been around for ages. A true watch FOR the field did not have any complications.

Quite a few had chronographs, which are considered complications. That's about it, though. Tachymeters with rotating bezels can be useful for navigation or taking notes, but their intended purpose is redundant in such an environment, and they make shit harder to read.

For actual field purposes these days, I'd go for a simple movement; like the scout a few pictured above. I find normal bands annoying, though, which is why I like that Mackinaw Field Watch with the pad. Let friction hold it on, rather than tension.

I like the the Scout more, but this band pad thing can be used on any of them, and I can swap them out if I like later; selling the Mackinaw on to pay for a Scout if it's just not my thing.

Shilnola seems to have the "look" squared away but I too have to admit that I wouldn't pay $500 for a watch with a quartz movement built by newly trained watch makers in Detroit. Hamilton still makes a great mechanical watch with an ETA movement. Watches are like wine though - There's no such thing as the "best" watch.

Shinola has people watching over the workers, and a quality check for each watch by someone with more expertise at the end of the line. They make good stuff, and they're pretty open about how it all happens, because it was known well ahead of time that the company would be under a microscope.

No matter how hard people try to pick them apart, though, there's still a high quality watch at the end of it all, and U.S. citizens were employed to produce them in a much better environment than they would have had otherwise.

Their partnership with Filson only added to that, given Filson's existing domestic manufacturing connections. A lot of stuff happens in the U.S. to make it all the way from cow to watch band.

As for your last comment, watches are a bit like cameras. The best watch is the one you've got with you when you need it. There is no single best watch. There exist bad watches, though, better watches, and those suited for certain purposes; but no best watch.

I recognize your position, but there are indeed other considerations, and Shinola has done their best (within reason) to address them.

Cheers,

Kennith
 

jim-00-4.6

Well-known member
Sep 30, 2005
2,037
6
61
Genesee, CO USA
Re: Decently Priced Field Watched

No, it's because they are really nice watches.
I like Shinola more than I like the TAG. Not in a small part because I can barely see Tag's slim hands on top of a black dial - compared to that:

watches_s_01_00111_f2_1150x1150.jpg


That's all I ever need in a watch, field or not. Leather strap will eventually have to go.
I don't know that watch from shit.
 

jim-00-4.6

Well-known member
Sep 30, 2005
2,037
6
61
Genesee, CO USA
Re: Decently Priced Field Watched

After sifting through seemingly hundreds of Timex expedition watched I'm going with the axe Expedition Scout w/olive NATO band. I really just don't need the chronograph feature but they look sharp
Can I get a watch with a Soviet Bloc band instead of a NATO band?
 

emmodg

Well-known member
Apr 17, 2006
4,273
1
Re: Decently Priced Field Watched

Time will prove whether Shinola makes a good watch. Not one of us.

Shinola and Filson are as "attuned" to watch making as Kenneth Cole, Boss, Hilfiger, or any other fashion watch making money on design trend. Off the shelf QUARTZ movements and off the shelf cases don't make a great watch maker. The Filson watch is yet another example of a great brand diluting it's history. You'll be able to buy Filson and Shinola on TMZ and watchuseek for pennies on the dollar. That is an honest to God garuntee!
 

kennith

Well-known member
Apr 22, 2004
10,891
172
North Carolina
Re: Decently Priced Field Watched

Time will prove whether Shinola makes a good watch. Not one of us.

Shinola and Filson are as "attuned" to watch making as Kenneth Cole, Boss, Hilfiger, or any other fashion watch making money on design trend. Off the shelf QUARTZ movements and off the shelf cases don't make a great watch maker. The Filson watch is yet another example of a great brand diluting it's history. You'll be able to buy Filson and Shinola on TMZ and watchuseek for pennies on the dollar. That is an honest to God garuntee!

Nope.

Shinola knows plenty about watch making from every angle. The company has been seamlessly functioning alongside Swiss part suppliers, experts in watchmaking, and training programs. American-made products flow smoothly in and out of the factory right alongside imported parts.

Yes, a part from Switzerland is an "imported part".

The operation was fired up with absolute precision in a difficult area for business, with a keen eye on the unemployment of people familiar with assembly work and receptive to training. It's one of the cleanest roll-outs of such an venture that you'll ever see.

Why?

That's simple. Tom Kartsotis, the guy behind Bedrock Manufacturing, hatched the whole operation. That matters, because he's the one that created Fossil out of thin fucking air and built it into a timekeeping powerhouse. The man bloody well knows timepieces, and knows how to leverage assets from countless directions to make things happen just the way they need to.

He also knows marketing. He knows people want a domestic product, but he's figured out exactly how much they're willing to pay to gain entry into the "Made in the U.S.A." club. He's tailored the entire operation to maximize domestic production, and balance it out with the Swiss "brand" of expertise. The man is a genius in that respect.

It takes a scalpel of a mind to put together such a perfect recipe; especially if you mean to end up with a good product, and he's ended up with an excellent product.

Make no mistake: Shinola knows watches as well as anyone; and so does Filson. After all, they're both owned by Bedrock now.

Filson has a renewed approach to domestic procurement, as well. They were struggling, and some of the strange offerings you've seen lately have been attempts to determine what people are willing to buy; so are the seemingly randomized sales. It's being carefully orchestrated, and I hope buyers respond well.

Recently, they tried a fully U.S. produced coat, made of U.S. sourced materials, at three different prices in each season. If you keep your eye on the ball, you can track this stuff. Very little information remains behind closed doors if you peek through every time someone opens them.

This fucker is good. He's very good.

Cheers,

Kennith
 

jymmiejamz

Well-known member
Dec 5, 2004
6,008
361
35
Los Angeles, Ca
My next big gift to myself will be either a GMT or a Sub.

Living in NYC has made me not like the Sub as every pretty much every investment banker buys one with their first bonus. Seems like a basic bitch watch to me, but I am no watch connoisseur . I love the GMT and Explorer II.
 

Stamos

Well-known member
Mar 15, 2009
264
5
Everyday watch (Rangeman) and my pride and joy PAM 569 Destro.
 

Attachments

  • Rangeman.jpg
    Rangeman.jpg
    32.5 KB · Views: 15
  • Destro.jpg
    Destro.jpg
    89.1 KB · Views: 19

p m

Administrator
Staff member
Apr 19, 2004
15,634
864
58
La Jolla, CA
www.3rj.org
What blows my mind with G-Shock is how tiny is the fraction of watch face real estate given to actual time display. And its overall design and appearance is pure "99c" store from early 90s.

But that's just me.
 

Mike_Rupp

Well-known member
Mar 26, 2004
3,604
0
Mercer Island, WA
What blows my mind with G-Shock is how tiny is the fraction of watch face real estate given to actual time display. And its overall design and appearance is pure "99c" store from early 90s.

But that's just me.

I've been thinking about getting a beater watch for this year's grape harvest. Last year, I trashed the dial on my Speedmaster Pro and it's at Omega getting a reconditioning. I can't bear the thought of fucking it up again.

As I was looking on Amazon, I found this watch that looks eerily similar to a Casio that I got as a Christmas present when I was maybe 10 years old: Casio Men's GWM5610-1 G-Shock Solar Watch with Black Band https://www.amazon.com/dp/B007RWZHXO/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_826OxbPBC12DS

My only hesitation is the red line on the face, but I love the cheesy 1980's LCD characters.