RBBailey said:
Humans aren't bears. And until you see differently, you won't understand that we don't give each other rights.
If we do, we are screwed. That would mean any one right could be deemed more important than others for arbitrary reasons. Or that any one agenda-driven right could be counted as more important by any one group or individual. It would also mean that any right we have has just as much validity being given as it does being taken away. In short, it would mean Hitler was right.
Jefferson in particular was very specific (and I know you are probably smarter than he was, but...) he made sure to state that the purpose of a government is to preserve rights, not to create them.
Im not claiming to be smarter than TJ. At the same time, I had to take a shitload of math and science in my field of study and dont consider myself a fool either.
Yes, in an optimal human-centric society a government should preserve basic rights, not establish them. As you pointed out with ze germans, this does not always happen because governents are run by people and people are flawed, some more so than others etc. etc...
However, if we are put in a situation/society where we are not placed on a pedestal above other creatures, our supposed rights are of little consequence to said creatures and are thus rendered meaningless. I.e. our rights only hold merit in the company of other humans. If we only have rights in the eyes of each other, wouldnt that mean that we bestow them upon each other for the sake of each other?
As I said, you do not need be a Christian or a believer to understand that there must be something beyond humanity that we at least need to pretend that our rights come from, or none of it matters.
This is probably why our views dont sync.
Im not sure that anything "matters".
Millions of years from now, our sun will run out of gas, expand, and envelop the inner planets of our solar system. Unless we figure out a way to get off this rock and survive elsewhere, there isnt gonna be anything left of us other than some space probes and radio signals floating around.
In the mean time, I just try to be happy without infringing on the happiness of others.