This is actually Alyssa...
We just sold the defender today, and now with the BMW not running at all, and the '59 not terribly practical (or insured for) daily driving, we're down to just the LWB. So the search is on, and quick.
Ron detests Audis. I don't really understand why, but to each his own. Ferraris are beautiful works of art, but are SO uncomfortable. We traded one recently and thought about it, but could barely stand driving it around the lot.
As for why a nice car... Why not? I know we're skewed by where we live, and also where I work doesn't help things. We've got the funds & we both want a nice car, so what's the problem?
We got the BMW so we would have something reliable and really nice, that I would enjoy and Ron would enjoy. It ended up being a nightmare with more problems than any 10+ year old vehicle we've ever owned-- and now has had TWO fires. Unfortunately, neither of us like the MB E320 (too mushy), Ron won't get an Audi, I can't stand Lexus, Acura, Infinity, and the US doesn't produce anything I'd like to buy. The X and S Type Jags are just ugly and disguised American cars, and the XJ is a little too $$$. I love Volvos, but they are a little too "family" for us right now. I would like to get a used new RR, and hope that would be the direction we go, but the darn things aren't depreciating that much, so they are still way up there in price. Neither of us fit in a Discovery II or a Freelander, so we've never gone that direction. Ron doesn't fit in a Boxter, which would have been a great choice. We looked at the new 911, and I have to admit I really like it, but the dog won't fit comfortably, and neither will any luggage. I didn't have enough leg room in the old 911. While that would be really nice, it just isn't practical (and again, the $$$ is quite high). My requirements are leg room, copious lumbar support, heated seats, CD, room for the dog (but I'm ok with a rear seat that people can't fit in, since we rarely have people in the back), comfy for a long trip, and room to fit luggage for a trip AND the dog at the same time). I would really LIKE navigation and a sunroof, but I could live without. Ron's recently gotten on this kick that he doesn't want a new car, only old cars that have already depreciated so much they will barely change in value. I'm sick of driving old cars and want something nice, luxurious, and new.